Skip to main content
All articles
AccessibilityUX

Your videos have captions. Can people actually follow them?

Julien Côte3 min read

If you post videos on your website or social pages, you've probably switched captions on, or paid someone to add them. Captions are the text on screen that matches what's being said. Most people assume that once they're there, the job is done.

WebAIM, the accessibility team at Utah State University, published a useful piece on this at the end of October. Their point: having captions and having captions people can rely on are not the same thing.

What captions are for

Captions are essential for people who are Deaf or hard of hearing. Many hearing people use them too, on a train, in an open-plan office or late at night with the sound off. They're required by the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), the international standard that most accessibility laws point to, under success criterion 1.2.2.

WCAG's own explanation, quoted in the article, sets out what that means:

"Captions not only include dialogue, but identify who is speaking and include non-speech information conveyed through sound, including meaningful sound effects."

Getting the words right is only part of it

Automatic captions have come a long way. WebAIM notes that a growing number of tools now do a good job of turning speech into accurate text. But words alone leave gaps: who is speaking, the phone that rings, the music that tells you the mood has changed, and how long each line stays on screen.

"Low-quality captions may present an inconvenience to some users but can completely exclude others who rely on them to access video content."

The article makes another point worth knowing: paying for captions doesn't mean they're good. The author has seen captions sold as professional that came out worse than what automatic tools produce.

A check you can do today

Pick one video on your website. Turn the sound off, switch the captions on, and watch it the way someone who can't hear would. Ask yourself four questions. Can you follow every word that matters? Can you tell who is speaking when it changes? Do important sounds appear, like a doorbell or a change in music? And does each line stay on screen long enough to read, without covering something you need to see?

WebAIM's advice is to check captions in the video player your audience will actually use, rather than just checking that a captions file exists.

"The measure of caption quality is whether viewers can rely on the captions to understand the message of a video."

Where this fits on your website

Videos often sit at the top of a homepage or a service page, because they explain what you do. If the captions miss the point, some of your visitors miss it too. It's one of the things we look at when we go through a website the way your customers use it.

If you'd like to see how your website works for everyone, including people who rely on captions, send us your website address and we'll record a free video walkthrough of what we find.

Source: Captioned Doesn't Always Mean Accessible, WebAIM, 29 October 2026

Written by

Julien CôteCôTEDESIGNS

Want to know where your site stands?

Our Accessibility & Conversion Sprint is a fixed price of £3,000. We test your key pages against WCAG 2.2 AA with a keyboard and screen readers, then fix what we find. If you'd like to see first, send us your website and we'll record a free video walkthrough.