The accessibility complaint that was marked "Solved" with nothing fixed
Julien Côte3 min read
Early this month, a blind listener enjoyed a podcast and wanted to share it. They couldn't. The share buttons on the episode page were just icons, with no text a screen reader could read out. A screen reader is software that reads a page aloud for people who can't see it, and it announced each one as "button".
Aaron Di Blasi, who publishes Access Information News and distributes that podcast for his clients, wrote up what happened next. It's worth reading for anyone who runs a website, because the problem wasn't really the buttons.
"Share icons with no labels. On one of the largest podcast distribution platforms in the world."
What happened to the complaint
On 4 November he reported it to the hosting company's support team. He explained the problem, gave an example page and suggested the fix: a short text label on each button, such as "Share on Facebook". He also listed a play button the keyboard couldn't reach.
The reply came the same morning. It was polite, said the information had been passed on, and added:
"Unfortunately, we will not be able to provide any timeline to these updates"
Two days later an automatic email arrived:
"Your ticket status has therefore been updated to solved."
According to the article, the buttons were still unlabelled when that email arrived.
Why this happens in ordinary businesses too
Nobody in that story set out to ignore a blind customer. The complaint landed in a general support queue, got a friendly answer and then closed itself because no one owned it. The same thing happens with a contact form, a shared inbox or a reception email address.
And most people never complain at all. When a website stops them, they leave and use someone else. The few who do write in are giving you the chance to keep everyone else.
Three things to put in place
First, a clear way to report a problem on every page, which works with a keyboard and a screen reader. Second, one named person who decides what gets fixed and by when, so a report can't close itself. Third, a reply that says what you'll do, followed by a second message when it's done.
Di Blasi ends his signature with a line that sums it up:
"The greatest barrier to accessibility is indifference."
If you'd like to see how your website works for everyone, send us your website address and we'll record a free video walkthrough of what we find.
Source: Libsyn.com: A Case Study in How Accessibility Requests Get Politely Buried, Access Information News (Aaron Di Blasi), 9 November 2026
Written by
Julien CôteCôTEDESIGNS
Want to know where your site stands?
Our Accessibility & Conversion Sprint is a fixed price of £3,000. We test your key pages against WCAG 2.2 AA with a keyboard and screen readers, then fix what we find. If you'd like to see first, send us your website and we'll record a free video walkthrough.